Diminutive 4 ¾” x 2 ½” glass flask with a silver plated detachable base cup. We like early sports related flasks (see September 28, 2014 post) and this one features an Association football which we have not seen before. The handshake design below the football may indicate membership in a fraternal organization. The flask has some great air bubble inclusions adding to its character.
Saturday, June 13, 2015
As football enthusiasts we are all aware of the aura around and exploits of Hobey Baker. Jacob and I have several really unusual football related photographs that include Baker that we plan to include as part of this post, but for now, since I have on occasion exposed my hockey alter ego, I once again diverge slightly.
The pictured hockey jersey is a game worn St. Nicholas Hockey Club jersey dating from the very few years that Hobey Baker played on that team. It is the only such jersey that we know of from this club and era that has come to light. The Alex Taylor label puts this jersey at no earlier than 1914, the company moving to the 26 E. 42nd St. address during that year. The label address and the distinctive style and variations with the stripe and St. Nicholas lettering put this jersey squarely in the timeframe of Hobey Baker, specifically the 1915-1916 or 1916-1917 time period, but probably not the 1914-1915 season. The back of the St. Nicks jersey has a sewn on number "2" that we originally thought may have been added later, but it may in fact be period, as we see in an International News Photo (copy of photo and close-up pictured) dating from the 1915/1916 time period a posed Hobey Baker in a St. Nicks jersey with a number on the back of his jersey. This photo was taken at a time in hockey when numbers were just beginning to be worn on the back of their jerseys and would have been added after the jersey was manufactured (a few years after numbered armbands and numbers on the fronts of jerseys were utilized).In fact in 1915 wearing a number was becoming more frequent and was required in championship games under the Championship Rules of the American Amateur hockey League. The players of each club shall be numbered, shall wear their numbers on the back of the jersey or sweater and as far as possible, shall retain the same numbers throughout a championship series.
This jersey has made it through a century and was of significance to someone who took great care to pass it down. Won't it be fascinating to determine who wore this jersey. After all, it was on the ice at the same time as Hobey Baker...
Jacob and I have acquired the matching St. Nicholas hockey pants/leggings that were split off as a separate lot from the jersey at the auction we had bought the jersey at. We did not know of their existence at the time due to the item description. It is fortunate from a research perspective that they have the original name tag of the owner sewn into them: Theodore B. Conklin Jr., who was a teammate of Baker’s on the St. Nicholas team. Rosters in 1916 and early 1917 have Conklin as Point (for example see NYT, February 18, 1917 article titled "St. Nicholas Stars Lose: Hobey Baker Unable to Stave Off 2 to 1 Defeat by Boston H.C." (one month before Baker’s last game for St. Nicholas)). This information was added to the blog on 02OCT17.
Baker, after graduating from Princeton (where he was known for excelling in both football and hockey) started playing for the St. Nicholas Hockey Club in 1914 and played for them during the 1914-1915 and 1915-1916 seasons. In 1916 Baker took up residence in Philadelphia and from November 1916 into 1917 Baker represented St. Nicks in their exhibition play. His last game representing St. Nicholas was in March of 1917, the St. Nicks vs. the Aura Lee team of Toronto (Ontario Hockey Association).
The final hockey game he played in was on March 24, 1917 when he played in an amateur All Star exhibition game which basically pitted Pittsburg against Philadelphia, played at the Winter Garden. Philadelphia won.
WWl came and went and Hobey Baker had played in his last hockey game.
Close up photo of the jersey – note: photo is printed in reverse
Potential search terms: St. Nicholas hockey club jersey , St. Nicholas hockey club , antique hockey jersey , Hobey Baker jersey , Hobey Baker hockey jersey
The Harvard University Foot-Ball Club was formed in December of 1872.
In its first full year (1873), membership certificates for this club were issued. Morton Prince, player and secretary for the HUFBC, designed and had made these certificates as well as a seal for this organization. The seal, made by Henry Mitchell (master engraver of Boston), features a round football, a motto of “Semper Surgens”, and the letters H.F.B.C. (see photo). Pictured is one of the earliest football documents in existence.
Morton Prince also authored a section of the H Book of Harvard Athletics (1923) entitled “History of Football at Harvard, 1800 – 1875 (June)” (pgs. 311 – 371), and he is considered the preeminent early Harvard football historian. This exact certificate is reproduced on pg. 351 of the H Book, as part of Prince’s work.
Morton Prince’s 1873 Harvard University Foot-Ball Club Certificate (or “Shingle”)
Close-up of the wax seal
The membership certificate was referred to as a “shingle” and required a one-dollar fee to purchase. This membership allowed for support of the organization and for members to play football recreationally as part of the club.
Interestingly, this shingle is the only example that would have been completed and signed by the team captain. It is signed by the football team’s captain, Henry R. Grant, as Morton Prince “did not wish to sign, as secretary, on his own shingle”, according to his accounting in the H Book of Harvard Athletics. This certificate remained one of Prince’s prized possessions throughout his life.
Harvard Rejects Yale’s Request
In October of 1873, Yale contacted Columbia, Harvard, Rutgers, and Princeton, proposing to establish an intercollegiate football association with a standard set of rules. Many from Harvard felt uneasy about Yale’s proposal. For example, the Harvard Advocate wrote on October 17, 1873: “If we should attend such a convention, as Yale proposes we should naturally feel bound to agree to the code of rules favored by the majority of the committee. It is evident that the result could not fail to be unsatisfactory to the football players at Harvard”. What was termed the “Boston game” was equivalent to the Harvard Game in 1873, in which “a player was permitted to pick up the ball, run with it, throw it, or pass it. He could also seize and hold an adversary to prevent him from getting the ball”. In contrast, the games played by the other four schools were essentially “all foot work” during this time. Given the drastic changes they would have needed to implement into their game, is quite understandable why Harvard might have viewed Yale’s request with apprehension.
Upon receipt of Yale’s letter by the HUBFC, a meeting was held by the officers of this football club (headed up by Captain Grant and Secretary Prince) and other members of this organization. It was at this meeting that Captain Grant and the rest of the team decided to reject Yale’s proposal to form an intercollegiate football association. In a letter from Grant to the secretary of the Yale Football Association, he explained the differences in the style of games Harvard played from the other institutions and, some say, tactfully belittled the others’ style of play. In his reply to Yale, Captain Grant states, “The feeling in the college was unanimous in maintaining our rules at the expense of matches with other colleges”. Harvard thus did not join the intercollegiate football association, and the path of American Football was forever changed.
Harvard plays McGill
In early 1874, Captain Gant received an unexpected letter from David Roger, captain of the of McGill University team in Canada, suggesting the schools play several matches against one another. Harvard’s Grant and Prince were the two key Harvard team members to work out the games’ specifics and the rules under which they would be played. The games needed to be played in Cambridge, as the Harvard administration would not allow the team to travel during the school year while classes were in session.
Two matches were scheduled for the 14th and 15th of May, 1874, at Jarvis Field in Cambridge. The first was played under Harvard rules, and the second under McGill’s rugby regulations. The McGill players showed up in uniform (the first time this had been seen by Harvard players) and the Harvard players, although not in their normal “oldest clothes”, appeared in white undershirts, dark pants, and magenta handkerchiefs on their heads. Still, the Harvard players were a bit embarrassed. They won the game by a score of 3-to-0, and fought to a 0-to-0 tie the following afternoon. This second match is considered the first intercollegiate rugby game to take place in America.
In each of these two games, the teams played with eleven men per side. The “Boston game” allowed for between ten and fifteen per side, although they were normally referred to as “the eleven”. McGill was accustomed to playing with any number between ten and twenty. Originally, the matches were to be played with fifteen men, however only eleven men were able to make the trip from Montreal.
In the famous composite photograph from the Harvard vs. McGill 1874 fall contest, when Harvard travelled to Montreal, Morton Prince is easily recognizable. I have him circled in the photograph. I have also included a photograph of the Harvard’s spring 1874 foot-ball team, inclusive of Captain Grant. In the fall of 1874, Arthur Ellis assumed the position of Captain.
Harvard vs. McGill, Fall of 1874. Morton Prince is circled.
Harvard University Foot-Ball Club Captain Henry Grant is seated at center
This certificate, or shingle, is an extraordinary example of football documentation from the absolute earliest days of football. Certainly the most significant early American football document that we are aware of. It stems from two of the most pivotal players from an historic and crucial phase of the game. Harvard’s rejection of the style of play that constituted association football in 1873 and its subsequent adoption of the rugby game as a result of the Harvard games against McGill in 1874 are the only reason we have football today as we know it and not a game than more closely resembles soccer. In the words of Morton Prince, “If Harvard had not refused (to join the Association …) it is highly probable that the modern game played today – like American Rugby – would ever have been evolved. Instead, all the Universities, colleges and schools today would be playing Association rules, - practically soccer”. After playing McGill, Harvard adopted their rugby game, considering it a worthy extension, even a superior replacement, for its own brand of football.
In 1876, the Intercollegiate Football Association was formed by Harvard, Columbia and Princeton using slightly modified rugby rules. The rest quickly fell into place and, as is stated so often, the rest is history.